When my father died unexpectedly and traumatically, my brother and I entertained a philosophical discussion on whether it’s easier for family members if death is sudden or if it is anticipated. At the time, we agreed that while we would wish a swift death for the sake of our parents, we would prefer to have the gift of time, to be able to converse openly about their wishes, and to mine their memory for family history.
You may have heard the cliché “be careful what you wish for.” Here I am, 5 years after my father’s death, facing my mother’s. She was recently diagnosed with inoperable Stage IV pancreatic cancer. The “inoperable” tag came after 2 hours of surgery intended to remove what was thought to be a small, isolated, resectable tumor.
As my brother and I sat in the surgical waiting lounge listening to her doctor, hopes for several more years were destroyed in an instant. Shock and numbness descended. The following days were spent in her hospital room, encouraging her to get up and walk in order to heal from the surgery.
It was not until Mom returned home that I began to process her diagnosis. As I sat on the sofa chatting with her about inconsequential matters, my mind was jumping to thoughts of what it would be like not to see her sitting in her favorite chair. By her second week home, I knew that I needed to find a way to balance living fully in the moment with preparing for how to deal with the progression of her illness.
Anticipatory grief takes many forms. It is much broader, and more complex, than anticipating the inevitable death of a loved one. It also involves a myriad of losses along the way, letting go of dreams, mourning immediate changes, and redefining goals.
Anticipatory grief encompasses learning how to honor the past, celebrate the present, and relinquish the future. Two months prior to her diagnosis, my mother had attended the high school graduation of her oldest great-grandchild. She had lovingly told his sister, who had just completed her freshman year of high school, “You’re next.”
It is unlikely that my mother will attend my granddaughter’s high school graduation. She will not be led down the aisle like royalty at any of their weddings. Although this is the practical reality I must live with, I don’t want these to be the thoughts that dominate my mind. I don’t want my ability to enjoy time with my mother to be overshadowed by the knowledge that she is dying.
My mother and I agreed to have some time each week that would be “cancer-free.” During that time we are mother and daughter, chatting about great-grandchildren, her garden, books we’ve read. There are many times when we need to have difficult discussions and make decisions we’d prefer to ignore, but we’ve tried not to let those conversations take over our time together.
We look through photo albums and I jot down notes as Mom reminisces about the extensive traveling she and my father enjoyed. What Mom doesn’t realize is that, along with discovering my parents as people, I am building new memories that hopefully will sustain me through the dark nights I know lie ahead. I order the proverbial elephant in the room to sit and be quiet, and I let my mother’s stories wash over me. I prompt her with questions, a subtle way to accomplish life review without labeling it as such.
Along with balancing medical appointments with my work schedule, trying to decipher Medicare statements, choosing hospice services, and maintaining my own home, I am learning much about how to live while dying.
Nina Bennett 2012
Nina, my dear, I’m so sorry to learn of your mother’s serious illness. Please know that as you cope with whatever lies ahead, I am holding you and your mother in gentle thought and prayer. ♥
Nina, I am sorry to hear about your Mother. I just lost my Dad in September 24, 2012 because of stage 4 colon cancer. He fought really hard for 2 years and 2 months and I always said before he passed away that I wish he would have had a fast death and not had to go through all the suffering. I dont know exactly how you feel or what you are going through, I know that I have been in kind of the same situation. I cant promise it will get any easier. I am still crying about the pain and suffering he was in before his death and I am mourning his death. I will keep you in my prayers and all I can say is hold on to your Faith and God will get you through this. I am only 27 and my Dad passed at 52. He was to young and too good of a person to go through this, but I have to trust God.
Marty and Nikki, thanks so much. Your words mean the world to me. Nikki, I am so sorry for your situation and your grief. You are right, your father was way too young, and you are way to young to not have him around. I appreciate your kind, loving thoughts.
Dear Nina
My father died suddenly of a heart attack after an operation for bowel cancer nearly 2 years ago and I always regretted that I did not get to say a propery goodbye to him. However I can see now from reading your account of your mother’s illness that it was better for both of us – not just him – because our final moments were ones of joy not sadness and I can see now that he would have loved to have talked to me but did not do so for my sake. My mother is still alive and we are very close and I do not know how or when her death will come but I am better prepared for reading your description of your mother’s death (e.g. having weeks when you would not talk about practicalities etc). Not that I actually think it makes much difference how or when a parent dies the whole point is you have to learn to live without them which is one of the hardest things in life. I wish you all the very best on your journey – as I am on mine. Thank you for sharing – you helped me.
Sue, thank you so much for taking time to comment. I agree that we are never prepared to lose a parent. At the time I wrote the article, my mother was still alive, and I was anticipating her death. She has since died, and it has been much more difficult than I expected. She did not want to discuss her diagnosis or her impending death, and as a healthcare professional who specializes in end-of-life issues, I felt like a failure. A hospice worker livingly reminded me that I permitted my mother to spend her final time as she chose. I also wish you all the best on your journey. We will carry them always, both genetically and through our love for our parents.