Experience: The stern lights of a ship, which illumine only the track it has passed.
— Samuel Taylor Coleridge
Having experienced grief previously, I assumed I would be able to move on through life after the death of my mother in November 2010. I thought myself well prepared since I had spent the last ten years creating my new life after my son passed from injuries he sustained in an automobile accident.
While caring for my mother, I convinced myself that becoming knowledgeable about Alzheimer’s disease, its progress, symptoms and behaviors would arm me with the necessities to flow through the process with her. Talking with caregivers, professionals and attending seminars also provided me with information to recognize what I was observing and what she might be experiencing as she walked through the course of her disease.
The internet was also helpful in accessing immediate gratification when questions arose about difficult and different behaviors or an illness or symptom developed or when I was attempting to validate what I thought I was experiencing with her in regards to our changing and deteriorating relationship. All this was helpful, but only for the time that I needed it prior to her actual passing.
My son Zac passed in a hospital when we told the staff to remove the life support apparatus. I was prepared, in theory (which is located in the mind, not the heart!) for his body to cease to be. I was not prepared for the immeasurable pain that I was to experience after that moment.
But time produced a past for me; I chose to create a new life for myself and life transcended into a new reality. With my mother’s passing, a different set of skills were necessary to guide me through this new view of death.
Grief is different from person to person and from relationship to relationship. I did not have a Pollyanna idea about what would occur during the caretaking process and I was prepared to allow my mother to travel in her new world while I attempted to observe and understand her journey and care for this new spirit who was now my mother. I did not deny the anticipated grief to come. I just did not prepare myself for the differences in the grief and the issues to be faced after her death.
The pain and grief after Zac’s death was intense, overpowering and overwhelming. I was shattered and my destroyed world required re-creation. But my parental grief compelled me to recognize and confront loss in different forms and on a variety of fronts. The grief after my mother’s death was unique and the following were just a few of the components that have defined my process:
- Our family history died with my mother. Besides my personal relationship with her being severed, family dynamics changed, no more memories will be made that include the entire biological family and family history is permanently altered from the entire life’s previous experience. No more family lore can or will be communicated, shared or verified. The challenge is now to accept and rewrite the new history for our generation and the grandchildren.
- Roles changed from adult child to mature adult caretaker. (Roles changed during the caretaking period of her disease but a decision-maker role was established after the parental death.)
- Regardless of her diminishing state the last few years, I had to accept the physical death. Forewarning of impending death due to the disease is immaterial at this point and separate from the actual death. Secondary to this, when memories of the pre-illness mother returned, the loss of my “real” mother immerged and I had to transform that loss into memories of our “historical” mother.
- Although I have a solid belief in the afterlife and was relieved and happy for her to have shed this broken body, I also had to break the physical bonds that were created between us so that I could accept and transform my continuing life.
- I was relieved of my caretaker role, which not only absorbed much of my energy but affected other areas of my life. Her death: extinguished friendships I developed with her facility and Hospice caregivers (she was in Hospice three times) I also had to recognize and let go of the rituals I developed in the caretaking role like purchasing toiletries, clothes, etc, visits on a scheduled and unscheduled basis
- Additionally to above: Elimination of the role necessitated a change in focus to who am I now and who will I continue to be without the relationship with my mother.
I had a preconceived notion that I would experience the loss of self after her death but involvement in this process has proven much different from that experienced after Zac’s death.
It is a horrific challenge to observe a parent’s slow decline and ultimate death but rewards can be gained through the grief journey if the choice is made to recognize them. I am so thankful that I was able to care for my mother and that I was a part of her life story. The learning in this chapter of my soul would not have been possible and I am so grateful that she helped write this one for me. My story would have concluded with different gifts. The pain has been worth the benefits of this relationship.
One must be willing to experience the pain, open and search their heart and re-create the new you. I am so thankful that I had the rich opportunity to learn from two great teachers in my life. I was blessed for the two of them enabled my ship to illumine two tracks and I am so grateful to both of them. Their lights will forever guide me as I choose to revisit their positive memories over and over again…
Chris Mulligan 2011
Chris, The title of your story caught my attention as I was exploring the Open to Hope Foundation’s web site. I recently wrote WHEN ALL THAT’S LEFT OF ME IS LOVE: A DAUGHTER’S STORY OF LETTING GO (Tate Publishing; release date Aug. 2, 2011) about the year leading to my mother’s death following a diagnosis of terminal cancer and the first few months after she died. Like you, I experienced both the pain and the beauty associated with this journey, and my grief was balanced with equal measures of gratitude.
And like you, I experienced the contrast between anticipated loss and sudden death.
My father-in-law died suddenly and unexpectedly of a massive stroke just five days before my mother eventually succumbed to her disease. Within the span of a single week my children lost two grandparents — one who had been expected to die and the other we expected to live forever!
In my book I touch on the very different ways my father and my mother-in-law experienced their grief following the loss of their spouse. One of them had had the chance to prepare and say goodbye, but he also had to endure the excruciatingly difficult challenges associated with knowing his beloved wife of 52 years was going to die — way too soon. The other was spared the agony of that long goodbye but was robbed of the opportunity to leave nothing unsaid and to prepare emotionally for the void in her life.
In the book I wrote, “Is it better to lose someone suddenly and unexpectedly than to lose him or her after a long illness one knows is terminal? That’s a question so many have wrestled with, probably because there is no answer. (Can one option be better when both are so awful? Are there degrees of terrible?)”
In my mother’s case, it was good – and I am grateful – to have had the time we had with her after diagnosis. Like you, I believe “the pain has been worth the benefits.” (In this pre-release period leading up to Aug. 2, you may read about my book, if you’re interested, on its FB page — search Linda Campanella, Author.)
Although I can relate to your feelings regarding the loss of your mother, I cannot even imagine your pain and grief following you son Zac’s death. (I have three sons.) I hope the hole in your heart continues to heal a little more with each passing day.
Linda Campanella
West Hartford, CT
Linda, Thank you for your comments and your compassionate understanding. We certainly share some similar intense elements in our maternal relationships.(and I am sure you will continue to hear from many others like us) I am so grateful that you wrote about your grief journey and encouraged and inspired others with your message about enjoying and embracing life in the face of death.
I am looking forward to reading your book as I am sure it will offer us hope and insights as we confront the inevitable with my husband’s journey through COPD/emphysema.
Linda, thank you for writing When All That’s Left of Me is Love: A Daughter’s Story of Letting Go and I wish you continued grace through your journey… Chris
Hi, Chris. I haven’t been back to this blog site in a while and am not quite sure what led me here today. I was pleased to discover your response, but sorry to learn you are on yet another difficult journey.
If you’ve had a chance to read WHEN ALL THAT’S LEFT OF ME IS LOVE in the months since our initial exchange, I hope it was a source of comfort and inspiration. Readers seem to be really loving it and are sharing with me their own stories (about their own moms, their own losses, their experience with hospice, their newfound resolve to make every day count and to cherish loved ones who are still alive) , which I am loving! I’m connecting with many people, as I did with you, in a deep place of shared humanity and vulnerability; it’s been truly wonderful – and my mother would be so pleased.
Although my book is a story born of death (my mom’s), it is much more about loving and living than about dying and grieving, and it may actually be an even greater source of strength as you travel the road of life with your husband than as you continue to come to terms with your painful losses. Every day can be a source of great joy, even if it comes in small helpings. In my mother’s case, her terminal diagnosis did not terminate life; in fact, it may have inspired us to live life more fully and joyfully than ever.
May all your days be filled with joyful living, heartwarming memories of loved ones gone, and many unexpected gifts such as those your mother and Zac surely continue to provide!
Sending you strength (though you seem to have a deep and wide reservoir already!) and many good wishes.
Linda